Compliance & Regulation Threat Intelligence Industry Awareness

House of Lords calls for mandatory business resilience stress tests as UK faces growing threats

By
3 Minute Read

BT has access to just two vessels capable of repairing damaged undersea telecommunications cables around the UK. One is French-owned and generally unavailable. The other is UK-based and 35 years old. That limited repair capacity is among the vulnerabilities highlighted in a new House of Lords report examining whether Britain is prepared for major disruptions to its critical infrastructure, at a time when government briefings have repeatedly raised concerns about Russian vessels operating near the subsea cables carrying much of Britain's internet traffic and international financial communications.

 That detail sits inside "Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience," a report published on 16 November by the House of Lords National Resilience Committee after a nine-month cross-party inquiry. The committee's verdict, in the words of its chair, Baroness Jean Coussins: the government "appears complacent, and the UK is underprepared." The report itself goes further, calling the UK "seriously underprepared for major, interconnected threats."

The committee's central argument is about how those threats connect to each other. Emergency planning across government, Coussins said, still tends to treat a power failure, a cyberattack and a transport disruption as separate problems, planned for separately, when in practice one triggers the next. Her own example: "A cyber-attack can quickly morph into a power cut, then a shutdown of transport, then empty food shelves in the shops." The committee's term for this is a polycrisis: several disruptions compounding at once, rather than one emergency at a time.

Mandatory stress-testing for essential businesses

The recommendation most likely to land directly on a security or continuity desk is this: the committee wants mandatory preparedness requirements and regular stress tests for businesses it considers essential to national resilience, backed by a Chief Resilience Officer at Permanent Secretary level to oversee it centrally. That's a markedly different proposition from the voluntary guidance and sector-specific frameworks that currently govern business continuity planning across most of the economy. The report doesn't yet define which organisations would fall inside "essential," but it points toward the same broad category already used in critical national infrastructure regulation: energy, water, transport, telecoms and the supply chains underneath them.

Two sector-specific findings give that proposal some shape. The committee wants water companies to demonstrate they can maintain emergency supply and distribution during a prolonged outage, not just describe their contingency plans on paper. And it names medicine supply directly: the UK has had no domestic antibiotic manufacturing plant since the last one closed in 2025, leaving the country dependent on imported active ingredients, much of it from China. The committee's recommendation is to rebuild some of that domestic production and review stockpile levels, rather than assume the global supply chain will hold under pressure.

Food retail gets the same treatment. Nine retailers account for roughly 94.5% of UK supermarket food sales, moving stock through a relatively small number of distribution hubs, with most of the system built around frequent deliveries rather than held reserves. The committee's concern isn't that this system is poorly run; it's that a system built for efficiency has very little slack left in it when something upstream goes wrong.

The threat picture behind the recommendation

The report attributes part of the urgency to a specific, named threat environment: hostile activity from Russia, China and Iran, including cyberattacks, sabotage of undersea cables and pipelines, and proxy violence. It cites more than 90,000 attempted cyberattacks against UK defence systems annually, and estimates the wider economic cost of cyberattacks to the UK at £14.7 billion a year. The committee also raises a NATO compliance question directly: whether the UK can currently demonstrate it meets NATO's seven baseline requirements for civil preparedness, and recommends regular public reporting against them.

None of this is presented as speculative. The committee's own evidence-gathering ran for nine months and drew on written and oral submissions from engineers, infrastructure operators, emergency planners and former officials, a process that sits behind the headline findings rather than replacing them.

What the committee wants to change, beyond the stress tests

Several of the report's other recommendations are aimed squarely at how government itself is organised, rather than at businesses. It wants a Cabinet minister with sole responsibility for resilience, an annual statement to Parliament from the Prime Minister on the country's preparedness, sustainable funding for Local Resilience Forums (the local bodies that coordinate emergency response), and progress on the Defence Readiness Bill. It also wants the planned switch-off of digital terrestrial television scrapped, on the grounds that broadcast TV remains a fallback communications channel in a crisis that mobile networks and broadband can't always guarantee.

On the public side, the report pushes toward something closer to the Nordic model of civil preparedness, where governments communicate risk openly and household-level emergency information is treated as routine rather than alarming. It wants expanded volunteer registers, broader participation in emergency exercises, and growth in the Armed Forces Gap Year Foundation Scheme as a way of building a wider pool of people with some relevant training.

What happens next

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said the government would review the committee's recommendations, pointing to the existing "Be Ready" household campaign, a national preparedness exercise planned for next year, and more than £1 billion already committed to pandemic security as evidence that resilience work is already underway. None of that commits the government to the stress-testing duty, the Cabinet-level minister, or any of the report's other asks, and select committee recommendations in the Lords carry no legal force on their own.

That leaves the genuinely open question for anyone running security, continuity or resilience functions: whether "essential business" ends up meaning the same organisations already caught by critical infrastructure rules, or whether it's drawn more widely. A report built around the idea that one disruption cascades into the next doesn't lend itself to a narrow definition. Organisations that assume this doesn't apply to them because they're not an energy company or a water utility may want to read the committee's own reasoning before deciding that.


Register your interest for The Security Event 2027

Subscribe to The Security Briefing for monthly updates!

Karyee Lee

Karyee Lee

Karyee Lee is a Content Executive for the Safety & Security Event Series, contributing to the digital content strategy and audience engagement across a diverse range of online platforms through The Security Briefing and Workplace Unplugged. Passionate about bringing industry professionals together, Karyee develops engaging digital content and supports initiatives that keep industry audiences informed and connected.

Author